Wiki Is Too Big To Edit

Wiki is TooBigToEdit.

Anyone else get this feeling? WikiAtThirtyThousand pages, more, now. Who knows how much duplication there is.

Here are some amusing numbers:

There may be another page on wiki that already has this exact content. (See also: TheLibraryOfBabel)

WikiPedia is larger, yet generally I find its quality is better than what I expected. So I think it is not a problem for the total value of the community to exceed an individual's browsing speed.

I see your point, but I think WikiPedia is considerably different from Wiki. The subject areas are quite different - WikiPedia has a very broad but shallow focus, and Wiki has a very narrow but deep focus. In addition to that, Wiki encourages authors to contribute their personal opinions, but WikiPedia expects that only verifiable facts be submitted. Verifiable facts and documentation tend to have well established names, which surely leads to less duplication. New opinions and discussion are highly personal and there are just as many possible names for a page as there are authors on Wiki. -- MichaelSparks


Try this to break the task down (Reading and Editing the Wiki):

Take the List of pages from RandomPages, Correct any errors you see in punctuation, spelling and grammar. Correct (if possible) any BrokenLinks? by entering the new Link pointing to a new location, or a page similar. Add and/or update items to provide up-to-date references.

Several version of RandomPages are provided each day, with the current one overwriting the old one. In this way of the perhaps 60 pages each day, for which corrections or changes might be needed to 25 percent, or about 15 pages, in a year, over 5000 pages will have been edited. That is approximately one sixth of the pages in wiki. In this way, one, two, or many persons will have edited the entire wiki in six or seven years. (No body said it was a small task). Other schemes might accomplish the task in as few as one or two years.

It isn't so much that WikiIsTooBigToEdit, as it is that Wiki can be edited by a relatively small number of persons, entirely, in an acceptable length of time.

I have started to do my part. -- DonaldNoyes 20060509


RefactorLowHangingFruit


EditText of this page (last edited May 9, 2007) or FindPage with title or text search