I read all the various comments about user stories and sense there is a serious lack of consensus regarding just what a UserStory is. English speakers typically think of a story as some kind of narrative that describes a WHO, WHAT, and WHY scenario. So, from that perspective, it is doubtful to me that a story is going to be at the brief, functional level a programmer needs to develop code.
Therefore, I suggest that the USER STORY is indeed a narrative that a user tells from her own perspective. This story typically describes some kind of scenario or situation that the user finds herself in. The programmers must then work with the user to derive from that narrative the specific USER TASKS that the user must to perform with the software to successfully accomplish the story.
For example, here is a real USER STORY:
What is your take on this Kent? Is there anyone else out there who is comfortable with this concept of User Story and User Tasks?
-- Martha Roden, Usability Engineer and Interaction Designer
What you have above are all sensible things to say, but they aren't a capital-S Story. A capital-S Story is:
Re: the details above. What is missing from this is "why". Why does the user want to do this. Story writing should be an opportunity for the customers to reflect on and refine their craft.
Kent
I like the idea of the "User Tasks", though in practice, many users (and developers) might initially frame some as "System Tasks". For example: "Require entry of a userID." versus "Enter UserID." I've been casting some user stories as use case scenarios, so my "User Tasks" end up being called "Scenario Steps".
Huet Landry
I am following this discussion on User Stories. But at this time I am a bit confused and want to see a UserStoryAndUseCaseComparison. For example, do we only document the success scenarios in a user story or do we also cater for failure scenarios or alternate flows as in use case? Without documenting the success and failure scenarios both, how can we get a complete picture of the work for the unit and therefore how can we write tests and estimate them?
Please give me some information on how to write user stories and what exactly to include in them?
Thanks
Samudra Gupta
Thanks a ton for that link on user stories and use cases comparison. One more thing I want to know is the use of coloured cards with extreme programming and agile methods. Any pointer on that please? I am seriously embarking on this on my next project.
Thanks
Samudra Gupta
In ExtremeOpenBusiness, a UserStory is given by making all UserInteractions? with the real market transparent, inspired by DaveBrin?s TheTransparentSociety. By transparently collaborating with OpenSource programmers (this is much more than "only" restricting programming to piecewise open releases of software sources to the public), the programmers get their real time-input from the users: e.g. EOB users, who practise SocialDomaining, by exposing their domain portfolios, as public Google Spreadsheets or EditGrid? Spreadsheets, via wiki pages. The users describe their needs on these wiki pages, e.g. we want a pay button in each row, that lets pop up a dialogue window, which initiates a transaction of domains and funds.